A climate claim can sound precise because it contains a number: emissions fell by 40%, a product is carbon neutral, or a company will reach net zero by 2050. That number is the result of an accounting process. Its meaning depends on the activities included, the data and assumptions used, and the basis for comparison. For journalists, the task is to establish what the calculation demonstrates before deciding how to report the claim.
Find the boundary of the claim
The first step is to identify its subject. Does it refer to a product, a facility or the entire company? A corporate emissions inventory and a product life cycle assessment answer different questions. A product assessment may consider emissions associated with raw materials, manufacturing, transport, use and disposal; a claim based on fewer stages needs to say so clearly. Likewise, progress in a company’s direct operations does not necessarily describe what is happening across its wider value chain.
A journalist should then compare the language of a press release or advertisement with the boundary used in the underlying calculation. If a company says it has reduced its “climate impact”, but the supporting figure covers only its offices and vehicles, the narrower coverage is part of the story. It may be a valid result, while leaving larger sources of emissions unanswered.
Establish what changed
A reported reduction needs a clear baseline and a consistent method of calculation. Journalists should examine the figures for successive years and ask whether changes in the business, such as an acquisition or divestment, affected the comparison. They should also distinguish a fall in total emissions from a fall in emissions per unit produced. Either can provide useful information, but they describe different outcomes.
Some changes reflect the way emissions are accounted for. For example, purchased electricity can be reported using a method based on the average emissions of the local grid or a method based on qualifying electricity contracts and certificates. These methods convey different information. When a claim relies heavily on a change in purchased electricity emissions, understanding which method produced the figure can be essential to explaining it accurately.
Separate emissions reductions from compensation and future plans
Terms such as carbon neutral and net zero require particular care. Journalists should establish the company’s reported gross emissions, the reductions it has achieved, and any use or planned use of carbon credits. A net figure that takes credits into account should not obscure the trend in emissions from the activities being reported. Disclosure guidance issued by the IFRS Foundation requires companies reporting a net emissions target under IFRS S2 to identify the associated gross target and explain any planned reliance on credits.
Targets also need to be reported in the correct tense. A commitment for 2050 is a future objective; current emissions and progress against interim targets show what has happened so far. The United Nations’ guidance on credible net-zero commitments distinguishes carbon credits from reductions used to meet interim emissions targets. This gives journalists a useful question: how much of a company’s claimed progress comes from changes to its activities, and how much depends on measures taken elsewhere?
Turn the investigation into an accurate story
Consider a hypothetical clothing brand that describes a new collection as “carbon neutral”. Its explanation says it has calculated selected product emissions and purchased carbon credits. A journalist would establish which stages of the collection’s life cycle were counted, how the emissions were estimated, whether the credits were purchased and retired for this claim, and what the company has done to reduce emissions in production and transport. The resulting story could acknowledge the action taken while making clear that compensating for estimated emissions and reducing those emissions are different developments.
Carbon accounting often relies on estimates, particularly where information must be gathered across a value chain. Uncertainty should be explained rather than hidden, and an unanswered question should not be presented as proof of deception. Journalists should request the relevant methods and figures, consult independent expertise where needed and give the company an opportunity to respond.
The strongest climate reporting allows readers to see the components of a claim: the emissions measured, the reductions achieved, the compensation used and the progress still required. Presenting those elements separately makes corporate climate action understandable and gives the public a sound basis for assessing it.