Corporate climate claims can appear precise and credible, particularly when they are supported by technical language, quantitative targets or references to recognised standards and initiatives. However, the existence of a target, indicator or sustainability report does not by itself demonstrate strong climate performance. Understanding what lies behind the claim is therefore essential.

When analysing corporate climate information, journalists should look beyond headline commitments and examine the scope, definitions, methodologies, assumptions and evidence supporting them. Certain characteristics can indicate that a claim provides only a partial picture of an organisation’s climate impact or progress.

Key red flags to examine

  • Omission or inadequate treatment of Scope 3 emissions: A company may report Scope 1 and 2 emissions while excluding significant emissions occurring across its value chain. For some sectors, Scope 3 represents the largest share of the overall climate footprint. Its exclusion can therefore substantially alter the picture presented.
  • Vague or undefined targets: Commitments such as “carbon neutral”, “climate positive” or “net zero” provide limited information unless their scope, baseline, timeframe and emissions coverage are clearly defined. A target should make it possible to understand what is being reduced, relative to what starting point, and by when.
  • Heavy reliance on carbon offsets: Offsets may form part of some climate strategies, but they should not substitute for credible efforts to reduce emissions directly. Journalists should distinguish between actual emissions reductions within operations and value chains and emissions that are compensated for through external projects or credits.
  • Lack of methodological transparency: Climate figures depend on choices about organisational boundaries, calculation methods, emission factors, assumptions and data sources. When these are poorly explained, it becomes difficult to verify results, reproduce calculations or compare performance across companies and reporting periods.
  • Inconsistent data across reports: Emissions figures, baselines or performance indicators may differ between annual reports, sustainability reports, corporate websites and other communications. Such differences may have legitimate methodological explanations, but unexplained inconsistencies deserve closer examination.
  • Use of unclear or potentially misleading terminology: Expressions such as “green”, “clean”, “low-carbon”, “climate positive” or “environmentally friendly” can convey strong environmental messages without specifying what they actually mean. The key question is whether such language is supported by clearly defined criteria and verifiable evidence.

The presence of one or more of these characteristics does not in itself demonstrate that a company is providing false information or engaging in greenwashing. There may be legitimate reasons for data gaps, methodological changes or differences in reporting scope.

Red flags should instead be treated as starting points for further investigation. They indicate where journalists may need to request additional evidence, compare disclosures over time, consult independent data, examine methodological notes or question the assumptions behind a claim.

For climate journalism, the objective is therefore not simply to decide whether a statement is “true” or “false”, but to determine what the claim actually demonstrates, what evidence supports it, and what part of the picture may still be missing.