Sustainability reports contain an increasing amount of quantitative information: greenhouse gas emissions, energy consumption, water use, waste, workforce indicators and many other ESG metrics. These numbers can appear objective and precise. However, ESG data is produced through methodological choices about what to measure, which activities to include, how indicators are calculated and what period or baseline is used.
For this reason, a number should rarely be interpreted in isolation. A reported 20% reduction in emissions, for example, tells us relatively little until we know 20% of what, compared with when, covering which activities and calculated using which methodology.
When interpreting ESG data, several dimensions deserve particular attention:
Boundaries: What does the number actually cover?
The first question is the reporting boundary. Does the information cover the entire corporate group or only selected operations? Are subsidiaries, joint ventures, franchises or international activities included? For emissions data, does the figure cover only direct operational emissions, or does it also include significant Scope 3 emissions across the value chain?
Changes in organisational boundaries can also affect reported performance. A company may sell a carbon-intensive business, acquire new operations or change which activities are included in its calculations. The reported footprint may therefore change even when the environmental performance of individual activities has not.
Metrics: What exactly is being measured?
Pay attention to whether indicators are reported as absolute values or intensity measures. Absolute emissions represent the total quantity emitted, while an intensity indicator expresses emissions relative to another measure, such as units produced, revenue or energy generated.
The distinction matters. A company can improve its emissions intensity — producing each unit more efficiently — while its total emissions continue to increase because overall production has grown. Both indicators can be useful, but they answer different questions.
Baselines: Compared with what?
Claims of improvement usually depend on a baseline or reference year. A statement that emissions have fallen by 30% is meaningful only when the starting point is known.
Check why a particular baseline was selected and whether it has remained consistent. Companies may legitimately recalculate baselines following acquisitions, divestments or methodological improvements, but these changes should be clearly explained. Otherwise, changing the reference point can make progress appear larger — or make historical comparison difficult.
Comparability: Are we comparing like with like?
ESG data becomes particularly useful when it allows comparison over time or between organisations. But apparent similarities between indicators do not necessarily mean that they were calculated in the same way.
Before comparing figures, check whether reporting boundaries, definitions, methodologies, units and emissions scopes are consistent. A company’s emissions this year may not be directly comparable with last year’s if the methodology has changed. Similarly, two companies reporting “carbon emissions” may be measuring substantially different things.
Data quality: How certain is the number?
Not all ESG data is based on direct measurement. Particularly across complex supply chains, companies may use estimates, industry averages, modelling assumptions or information supplied by third parties. This does not automatically make the data unreliable, but it affects the degree of certainty that should be attached to it.
Look for information about data sources, estimation methods, limitations and whether figures have been externally assured. Precision in presentation should not be confused with precision in measurement.
For journalism, the objective is not simply to reproduce ESG indicators, but to understand what those indicators allow us to conclude. Before using a figure, ask:
What is included? What is excluded? What is being measured? Compared with what? Has the methodology changed? And is this number genuinely comparable with the one I am placing beside it?
A useful discipline is therefore to treat every ESG number as having a boundary, definition, methodology and context. Understanding these elements can reveal differences that headline figures alone may conceal.